Bhutia and 14 former India players want the government to step in at the AIFF, a month before its election
Their letter to Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya calls the state of Indian football “pathetic”, and Kalyan Chaubey is trying to get back into the 20 December race through Karnataka.
Nov 21, 2026
Fifteen former India internationals, Bhaichung Bhutia among them, have written to Union Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya asking the government to “intervene immediately” in the All India Football Federation. Their letter is dated 17 November and goes after Kalyan Chaubey’s leadership without any softening. It calls the current state of the game “pathetic to say the least” and asks Mandaviya to “nominate someone with proven track record to lead the Federation for the coming term.”
The AIFF elects its next president on 20 December.
What the players say has gone wrong
The letter opens with the ranking. “Our international rankings have dropped drastically from 95 to 138 in the last 3 years,” the players wrote. They say the federation “has failed to organise a proper league in the country”, that clubs have shut down because nobody knew when the season would start, and they name Tata-owned Jamshedpur FC as one of them. Players have lost their income as a result, according to the letter.
They are just as hard on the friendlies against Brazil and Uruguay. The federation spent heavily on those games while short of money, they argue, and the Kolkata matches were played in “near empty stadiums” as a “publicity stunt”. Hosting them, along with Panama, also meant India missed FIFA’s new ASEAN tournament, the letter says.
The SAFF warning that did not age well
One of the letter’s worries was the SAFF Championship. The signatories said no proper camp had been organised and that India were at risk against Pakistan and Bangladesh in Dhaka. On the day the letter is dated, a second-string India side went a goal down to Pakistan in the final at the National Stadium and won 2-1, with Sandip Mandi heading the winner in the 88th minute. It was India’s third SAFF title in a row and their 10th in all.
That result does nothing about the bigger complaints over the league, the money or the ranking. But that particular warning has already been overtaken.
Chaubey and the 20 December vote
Chaubey, who kept goal for Mohun Bagan and East Bengal, became AIFF president in September 2022 when he beat Bhutia 33-1 in a vote of the state associations. He is now trying to get back into the race through Karnataka, whose association has put his name forward as one of its two representatives. The change came after the nomination deadline, so it needs the electoral officer’s approval. On Friday, Arvind Menon, president of the Uttar Pradesh Football Sangh, told PTI: “I have decided to contest the AIFF president’s election.”
The 15 who signed are Bhutia, Deepak Kumar Mandal, Arindam Bhattacharya, Renedy Singh, Anwar Ali, Dhanachandra Singh, Satish Bharti, Alvito D’Cunha, Manjit Singh, Balwant Singh, Sehnaj Singh, Karanjit Singh, Harpreet Singh, Baldeep Singh and Harmanjot Khabra. They are asking a minister to pick the federation’s leader rather than wait for its own vote. They warn that without a change at the top, reviving the game could take decades.





