Sancho has been unattached for two months, and the window closing does not stop anyone signing him

The summer window shut on September 1, and the usual line is that business is finished until January. It is not, quite. There is a group of players sitting outside the system right now who can be signed tomorrow if a manager picks up the phone, and the list this year is better than it has any right to be.

The rule, and the loophole it closes

A club can register a genuinely unattached player outside a transfer window. That is the part everyone knows. The condition attached to it is the part that gets forgotten: the player’s previous contract has to have expired or been terminated before the window closed. A club cannot release someone on September 5 and then re-sign him a week later, and it cannot buy a contracted player from a rival by having him torn up first. The exception exists for players already stranded, not as a back door into the market.

Signing one is still not a formality. Squad limits apply, registration has to be completed, and a player arriving from outside the country needs a work permit like anyone else. What it does mean is that a squad which loses a centre-back to a hamstring tear in October is not automatically stuck with what it has.

Benzema got out with a day to spare

Karim Benzema’s timing was almost comic. Al-Hilal agreed to terminate his contract on August 31, one day before the window closed, six months after he had joined them from Al-Ittihad and with a year still to run. At 38 he is a free agent by mutual consent rather than by anyone’s plan, and the honest reading is that his next move is more likely to be another Saudi club or retirement than a return to Europe.

Paul Pogba’s exit was quieter and sadder. Monaco tore up a deal that had until June 2027 to run, in the middle of August, after he had managed just six appearances for them. He is still without a club. The talent question was answered years ago; the fitness question never has been.

Sancho is the one worth an argument

Jadon Sancho is 26. That single fact is why he sits apart from the rest of this list. He left Manchester United at the end of June when his contract ran out, five years after an 85 million euro transfer that produced 12 goals and six assists in 83 appearances, with loan spells at Dortmund, Chelsea and Aston Villa in between. None of those clubs took him permanently.

Every version of the Sancho argument is uncomfortable. He was excellent at Dortmund, adequate in flashes since, and he has now spent two full months unattached in the middle of a career that should be at its peak. A club taking him on a short deal is not doing charity. It is buying a 26-year-old winger for nothing, which is the sort of bet that only looks obvious afterwards.

Two more who left through the exit door

Riyad Mahrez had his Al-Ahli contract terminated in early July, three years after arriving from Manchester City and having scored 37 goals in 122 games for them. He had retired from international football with Algeria a day earlier, after they went out of the World Cup 2-0 to Switzerland in the round of 32. That is a lot of endings in one summer.

Dani Carvajal’s was the most dignified departure of the lot. His contract expired on June 30 and Real Madrid decided against renewing it, which ended 23 years at the club counting the decade he spent in the academy. Trent Alexander-Arnold’s arrival and a body that had stopped cooperating did the rest. He is 34, he has won essentially everything, and there will be clubs across Europe who would take him for a season on the strength of what he knows alone.

Who actually signs one of them

Most of these players will still be unattached in October, and then someone’s first-choice full-back will pull a hamstring and the phone will ring. That is how this market has always worked. Clubs treat the unattached list as an insurance policy rather than a shop window, and they tend to remember they need one only after something has already gone wrong.

My guess is Sancho moves first and Carvajal moves best. One is young enough that a club can talk itself into the upside, the other is exactly the low-risk experienced signing a squad reaches for in November. Benzema, Mahrez and Pogba feel like different stories, and not necessarily ones that end with a European club.

Read more of our football features