Root returns as England’s Test captain, but Fleming does not start until December

England have filled the two biggest holes in their Test set-up on the same day, and one of the names will be very familiar to anyone who has spent the last two decades watching the IPL. Joe Root is captain again, four years after handing the job over. Stephen Fleming, who left Chennai Super Kings on 13 July after 18 years, is the new Test head coach on a four-year deal that runs to the end of September 2030.

The two appointments close a fortnight of upheaval. Brendon McCullum was removed from the red-ball role on 12 July after seven defeats in England’s last nine Tests. Ben Stokes had already announced during the Trent Bridge decider against New Zealand in June that he was retiring from international cricket, ending a captaincy that started in April 2022.

Root goes back to a job that once wore him down

Root is 35 and has already done this. He led England in 64 Tests between 2017 and 2022, winning 27 of them, and by the end of that spell the team had one win in his last 17 matches as skipper. He gave it up, Stokes took over, and Root went on scoring until he became England’s leading Test run scorer of all time. Free of the job, he was better at the other one. That sequence is exactly why the reappointment has raised eyebrows.

“It is a great honour and privilege to be asked to be England Men’s Test captain again,” Root said in the ECB’s announcement. “I am excited to lead this next generation of players forward.”

Rob Key, the managing director of England men’s cricket, framed Fleming’s arrival as the bigger prize. “Stephen Fleming is one of the most highly respected figures in cricket, and we are very fortunate that someone of his calibre is willing to take on this challenge,” Key said.

Fleming does not actually start until the winter

Here is the wrinkle. Fleming will not be in the dressing room for England’s next three Tests. Marcus Trescothick, already on the staff, takes the Pakistan series on an interim basis, starting at Headingley on 19 August and running through Lord’s and Edgbaston. Fleming arrives in the UK later this summer to prepare, and his first series in charge is the tour of South Africa, which opens in Johannesburg on 17 December before a Boxing Day Test in Centurion and a New Year match in Cape Town.

“I’m incredibly excited to be joining England as Test Coach,” Fleming said. “It’s one of the most prestigious coaching positions in world cricket and I am honoured to be appointed.”

Nobody is questioning the CV. Fleming is 53, played 111 Tests for New Zealand and captained them in 80 of those, winning 28, a mark no other New Zealand captain has reached. He got the job in 1997 at the age of 23 and remains the youngest captain New Zealand have appointed. The English part of his record is not a footnote either: he played for Middlesex, Yorkshire and Nottinghamshire, and led Nottinghamshire to the County Championship in 2005. Then there is Chennai. Five IPL titles in 18 years, and a working relationship with MS Dhoni that outlasted every rebuild the franchise put him through.

The Harry Brook question nobody has answered

The awkward part of the announcement is who did not get the job. Harry Brook, England’s limited-overs captain, was widely seen as the natural successor when Stokes stepped away, and was treated as the only credible alternative to Root. He did not get it. England went back to a 35-year-old who had already found the role heavy going once, which tells you something about how thin the leadership pool looks right now.

Mark Butcher, the former England batter, called the reappointment “a retrograde step for the team” on Sky Sports. “I just don’t think it’s the best move for him to be captain at this moment in time, or at any other moment in time actually,” Butcher said, pointing back at how Root’s first spell ended.

The counter-argument is simply time. England play Pakistan in under three weeks, all three Tests count towards the 2025-27 World Test Championship, and appointing a first-time captain into a side that has just lost its coach and its talisman is a gamble of a different kind. Root has done the job before and still knows the dressing room better than anyone in it.

What the next 12 months look like

Trescothick and Root have Pakistan at home. Fleming and Root then have South Africa away over the winter, a day-night Test at the MCG from 11 March 2027 to mark 150 years since the first Test, and a home Ashes in the summer of 2027 waiting at the end of it. The WTC cycle gives every one of those matches a number attached, which is a pointed change for a team that spent the Bazball years insisting the result mattered more than the table.

For Indian viewers, the strange part will be watching Fleming in an England tracksuit at all. He has been a fixture of the IPL for so long that CSK yellow feels like part of him. He inherits a side with a settled batting order, an unsettled bowling attack, and a captain who has been here before and did not enjoy the ending.

Stay across the latest from the cricket desk