Sanju Samson’s slump has reopened India’s most awkward selection call

India batted for twenty overs at Chester-le-Street on Wednesday, put 189 on the board, and then watched the rain take the game away before England could reply. The scoreboard says no result. The scorecard says something India will carry to Old Trafford anyway, because at the top of it, next to Sanju Samson’s name, sits the number one.

Samson opened, drove Saqib Mahmood straight to point, and was gone inside the second over with India 6 for 1. Ishan Kishan followed almost immediately, and it took a 59 from Abhishek Sharma and a composed half-century from captain Shreyas Iyer to haul the innings back to a respectable 189 for 7. The recovery was the story of the night. Samson’s dismissal is the story that will not go away.

Three innings, three single-figure scores

This is not one bad night in overcast Durham. Samson made 5 and 0 across the two T20Is in Ireland before this, so the England opener completes a run of 5, 0 and 1. For an opener, whose job is to use the powerplay and set a platform, three single-figure scores in a row is the kind of sequence that starts to shape a conversation rather than sit quietly in a spreadsheet.

What makes it jar is who we are talking about. This is the same Sanju Samson who was named player of the tournament at the T20 World Cup earlier this year, the man who walked out in the final and made 89 to help India lift the trophy. A batter does not forget how to do that in a few weeks. But reputations earned in March do not score runs in July, and the gap between the two is exactly the space a selection debate lives in.

None of it is fatal on its own. Openers go through lean patches, conditions in England in early July are not made for driving on the up, and a five-match series is a long runway. But form is only half of what makes this awkward for India. The other half is who is standing behind him.

The 15-year-old in the same dressing room

Vaibhav Sooryavanshi is in this squad, and he is a left-handed opener, which is exactly the seat Samson is sitting in. He is also 15 years old and coming off an IPL 2026 that reads like a misprint: 776 runs, the Orange Cap, a record 72 sixes, and the tournament’s Most Valuable Player award. He has not played a game for India yet. Every time Samson falls cheaply, the noise around that fact gets a little louder.

India have chosen patience so far, and I think they are right to. You do not hand a schoolboy his first cap as a panic reaction to a rained-off match, and throwing a 15-year-old into a high-pressure series because the crowd wants it is how you damage a talent rather than launch one. Sooryavanshi’s time is coming, but it should arrive as a plan, not as a flinch.

The real question is about Samson, not the teenager

That is the part worth separating out. Whether Sooryavanshi debuts and whether Samson keeps his place are two different decisions, and India would be wise not to tangle them together. The case for sticking with Samson is straightforward: it is one completed innings into the series, the Durham game was effectively washed away, and knee-jerk changes after a no-result rarely age well. Give him Old Trafford with a clean slate and see what a proper batting surface brings out of him.

The case against is the calendar. This is a five-game series, this India side has been picked to look forward rather than back, and an opening slot is the one place where the future is banging loudest on the door. If Samson walks out at Old Trafford on Saturday and the story is the same, the argument for patience gets very hard to make with a straight face.

My guess is that India give Samson at least one more go, and probably should. But the leash is short, and it would not be a surprise if a fourth low score turned the loudest debut clamour of the summer into an actual India cap before this series is done. Samson holds the answer in his own hands for now. He has one innings, maybe two, to make sure the question stops being asked.

More of our cricket views and analysis