CSK's opening night laid bare a problem that goes deeper than Dhoni's calf

Dhoni has been ruled out for the first two weeks of IPL 2026 with a calf strain. Ruturaj Gaikwad led the side in his place. Sanju Samson, acquired from Rajasthan Royals in the blockbuster trade that sent Ravindra Jadeja the other way, opened the batting. Jamie Overton top-scored with 43 from number eight. That last detail tells you everything about how the rest of the batting went.

The numbers are ugly

CSK lost wickets at regular intervals against Rajasthan’s pace attack of Jofra Archer (2 for 19), Nandre Burger (2 for 26) and Jadeja (2 for 18). Nobody in the top five passed 20. Samson, in his first outing in yellow, fell cheaply. Shivam Dube was dismissed by his former teammate Jadeja, who sent him off with his trademark firing-gun celebration. The whole innings lasted 19.4 overs.

Rajasthan chased the target in 12.1 overs. Vaibhav Sooryavanshi, the 15-year-old, smashed 52 off 17 balls. Yashasvi Jaiswal cruised to an unbeaten 38. It was not competitive.

Dhoni’s real value has always been invisible

The conversation around Dhoni tends to focus on his batting. His strike rate, his finishing, the sixes over long-on. But the bigger loss when he is not there is the structure he brings to the middle order. When Dhoni bats at seven or eight, everyone else knows their role. The top order can play freely because they trust what is coming behind them. The middle order can rotate strike because they know Dhoni will accelerate later. Take him out and suddenly nobody is sure who does what.

Gaikwad is a fine batsman, but captaincy in Dhoni’s shadow is a thankless job. Every decision gets compared to what Dhoni would have done. Every loss gets blamed on his absence. CSK have lost five of the six matches Dhoni has missed in IPL history. That is not a coincidence.

The deeper question

Dhoni will come back. The calf will heal, he will slot in at number seven, and CSK will probably start winning again. But what happens at the end of this season? Or the next? CSK have been building towards a post-Dhoni future for three years now and they are no closer to answering the fundamental question: who replaces the irreplaceable?

Samson’s arrival was supposed to help answer that. He can keep wicket, he can bat in the top three, and he is experienced enough to handle pressure. But his first outing suggested the adjustment to a new franchise is not automatic. He looked out of rhythm, and the team around him looked lost without its anchor.

Gaikwad needs games as captain without Dhoni watching from the other end to grow into the role. These two weeks might actually be the best thing that could happen to CSK in the long run, even if the results are painful right now. A franchise that has spent 15 years leaning on one man’s instincts has to learn to stand on its own eventually.

Monday was not just about a calf strain. It was a preview of what the future looks like if CSK do not find answers soon.

More cricket opinions